Transcript 0:00 The Charlotte Ledger Podcast is a member of the Queen City Podcast Network. [upbeat music] Hey, it's Tony Mecia with The Charlotte Ledger, and you're listening to the Charlotte Ledger Podcast. 0:12 Find out more about The Charlotte Ledger and subscribe to our newsletters at thecharlotteledger.com. Today, we're taking a closer look at the transit and transportation tax referendum that's on this November's ballot. 0:24 It's a $25 billion plan that would build rail and provide money for roads and buses by raising the Mecklenburg sales tax by one percentage point to 8.25%. 0:35 The Ledger is working with our news partners at WFAE, Charlotte's NPR station, to provide thorough coverage of this issue with our weekly newsletter, Transit Time, which you can find at transittimeclt.com. 0:48 Now, we've looked at it from all different kinds of angles. We've gone deeper on the different aspects of the plan, such as what exactly it would do and how much it would cost. 0:57 And as part of that, we've produced two podcasts that are conversations about the transit and transportation plan, one with a supporter and one with an opponent, and you can listen to each one and decide for yourself how to vote on this important issue. 1:10 We don't tell you how to vote. We're just giving you information. And as you will hear, these aren't arguments like you'd find on cable TV. 1:18 These are conversations, and my approach was to let each guest make his case and then ask some skeptical questions to probe them and push them a little bit. I think you'll get something out of it. 1:28 Today's conversation is with Robert Dawkins, an opponent of the plan. 1:31 He's the political director for Action NC, which works for racial, gender, and economic justice through organizing, leadership development, and voter engagement. 1:41 And again, if you wanna hear the other side, if you wanna hear the vote yes side, you can check out my conversation with Shannon Bins of Sustain Charlotte in an accompanying podcast. 1:51 But in this discussion, we're talking with Robert about why he thinks voters should vote no. All right, so Robert, thanks for joining me. Hey, glad to be here, Tony. 1:59 All right, so voters are facing a big question on this November ballot, and it's really whether to increase the sales tax in Mecklenburg County from 7.25% to 8.25%, and that money, they estimated at about $20 billion over 30 years, would go toward more buses. 2:16 It would go toward expanding rail, adding roads and sidewalks and other things related to roads. What's your take on why voters should vote no? 2:26 Well, first, I wanna say that Action NC is a progressive organization, and you can't be progressive if you don't believe that there should be a quality transportation system for people to use, and a quality transportation system would benefit our base, which is the low to moderate income base. 2:44 What we don't agree with is the inner workings of this plan. We do not believe that the authority is set up to be representative of the community. 2:55 We don't like the process that was used to come about the inception, from the inception to the point of it being passed, called the Pay That. We don't think that there was transparency or enough community input in it. 3:08 Uh, we don't think that there's been guardrails in this to make sure that low to moderate income people will not be hurt, since this is a regressive tax, or that services will be scaled back, like what happens every time there's a recession. 3:23 And, you know, for a multitude of reasons like those, we're opposed to, uh, this transit tax passing as a referendum on November the 4th. Okay. 3:35 I'd like to get into some of those a little bit, but I mean, I think the thing that you hear a, a lot of people on the other side saying is, "Well, okay, maybe this isn't the perfect plan, and maybe it's not the way s- they would've done it if they were drawing it up, but don't we just need to do something? 3:49 I mean, isn't the need so urgent that we need to, that we just need to go ahead and do this and get some of this stuff built, and we can kinda figure out some of these, some of these details on how to make it better?" 4:00 No, because, one, one of the main reasons that there wasn't transparency is that everyone is scared of our general assembly, and they're scared by saying, "Oh, if we don't, uh, do, if we don't make the plan the way that they want it, then we can't get it." 4:17 Well, you just got it, so you can't go and think that they're going to reform the plan that they already gave you. 4:24 So before you do what we would refer to as the Charlotte Way, which is have a great idea and a bad, bad plan and people suffer again, let's not make a $30 billion mistake that would come out and hurt us worse than where we are right now, and that's what will happen if we pass this. 4:42 It will be a $30 billion mistake that you will do irreparable harm to the community, and you've taken their money and helped displace them with their own money and said, "Well, we tried to help you, but it failed, and we're sorry. 5:00 We're gonna go back to driving, and unfortunately, you got displaced, so good luck living in Gastonia." 5:08 Y- yeah, so what do you think, I mean, what ex- what is exactly the harm, you think, to low and moderate income communities? I mean, what, what is that exactly? So first let's start with the economic impact. 5:19 And one, what I keep hearing people say is, "Oh, well, it's only gonna be 11 bucks a month." Well, 11 bucks a month is a lot when you don't have m- when you don't have money. 5:29 I've seen people in Charlotte complain about 11 buck a month tax increases a plenty of time, and that's what's for everybody. 5:39 Any time that the city says, "We gotta raise fees," any time Duke Energy says, "We've gotta raise your electric bill," normally it's about 10 or $11 a month, and everybody goes crazy. For my community, it's huge. 5:52 So if my community's already standing in line at Crisis Assistance Ministry to pay their light bill, which is 50 bucks a month, or if my community was already at their church asking them to help them with a bag of grocery because the grocery prices went up, then 11 bucks a month is a, is problematic, especially when some of the services you're trying to get them to require require extra things that that 11 bucks- Uh, may be problematic for. 6:19 And then Tony, here's the biggest piece. It's a regressive tax, which means poor people pay a larger share of their income to, to fund it, and I don't think they're getting a larger share of the benefit. 6:31 Because getting people to work 15 minutes faster to a job that's barely paying them, uh, enough to live is not transformable change. 6:41 Y- yeah, I mean, I think one of the things that the other side says is l- look, you know, it's, it's not just getting them to work 15 minutes earlier, it's you would have more people, you know, riding the bus because right now people, if the buses are coming every 30 minutes or every 45 minutes, you know, it's not really a realistic option, and sometimes they're not on time. 6:58 But if you could actually get them going on, you know, every 15 minutes, then more people would use it. You wouldn't have to have a car. I hear what you're saying, not everybody has a car to begin with. 7:06 But that, but that there are benefits to people to being able to have a, a reliable transportation system. Right, right. 7:12 What I hear is a lot of people trying to sell us, specifically the poor communities, on something that we're really not getting a benefit for, and that's why we call it a bait and switch. 7:25 If you just wanna build a red line, if you want economic development, call it that. 7:31 But to turn around and say, "Oh, we're going to give you some bus shelters for dignity," if you cared about my dignity, you would've built bus shelters already. 7:40 If you cared about my dignity, you would make sure that we had reserved spots on the authority so that we were represented. 7:47 If you cared about our dignity, the mayor herself has $75 million sitting in this mayoral fund that the city forgot about, use that for the bus shelters. A bus shelter, a great bus shelter costs you about $5,000. 8:02 $5,000 times 20,000 bus shelters is $10 million. Take that. Take 10 million out of that. That still leaves you 65 million. Take that 65 millions and pay for micro transit. 8:13 Now you don't have to raise my taxes because the person that's suffering the most in this tax is going to be poor people, and when it doesn't work the same way that it hasn't worked then before, then the city says, "Oh, well, we're sorry. 8:28 You know what we're gonna do? We're gonna start a task force and we're gonna study it, and hopefully we'll come out with a good slogan like Charlotte's Got A Lot." 8:35 So you touched on some of this, but what is it you would like to see them do? I mean, I know you're, you don't like this plan- Well, first- For some of, some of the reasons that you laid out. 8:42 But what, what are, I mean, and, and you said okay, they- they've got some money, maybe they could do some of these things, you know- Yes... without actually having a tax increase. 8:49 But w- if, if, if you were in charge, what would you do to improve transit and transportation? 8:54 First thing, first thing I would do is what they didn't do in January, and that was open up the process and make sure that everybody was being heard. 9:03 When we started asking the city questions, 'cause this was CATs, so we started on the city side back in February asking questions. 9:11 And what we heard was, "We don't wanna stir that pot up because we need to get the general assembly's ap- permission." 9:19 When we'd ask another question, it would be, "Well, we don't wanna stir that pot because we don't want the general assembly to get mad." 9:26 So you made a plan that you didn't want the general assembly to know much about because they might stop it. 9:34 You couldn't tell the public what you were thinking because you didn't want them to mess up your ideas that you were trying to formulate, so you made your plan in a silo. Let's start with that. Don't do that. 9:47 Don't make your plan in a silo. Make your plan all out in the public. 9:51 Next, if you do need permission from the general assembly, ask the community to go lobby for it and not the s- uh, Charlotte Regional Business Association. You ask us. 10:01 I saw when UNC Charlotte wanted a football stadium, they asked everybody to go to the general assembly. When folks wanted Fan- FanDuel wanted sports gambling, they asked everybody to call the general assembly. 10:13 When Charlotte wants something, y'all aren't smart enough to talk to your representatives 'cause you might mess up our plan, so we're gonna do it behind closed doors, and then we're gonna sell it on you. 10:23 So first we need transparent process. Second, we need to have the people that, that are responsible have it done on their watch. 10:32 There's no need for city council to do all the work and have the election on city council when this is a Mecklenburg transit bill, and the main people we need help from is the legislature. 10:42 So bring this plan and ask the general assembly representatives and ask the county commissioners what they're going to do, and hold them accountable by making them do it in an election year. That's two. 10:56 Third, I think the biggest thing that's important is providing for bus service to people and better busing. So I would use the quarter cent sales tax that the city already has. 11:06 I would put that on the, I would put that on the March primary ballot and ask the public if they wanna authorize a quarter cent sales tax for better busing and- And this is, this is the author- an authority that, uh, Mecklenburg County already has, the, from the arts tax that didn't pass. 11:22 Yes, the city passed. That one, right? Yeah, yeah. It's already there sitting there without any stipulations. They could go ahead and use that to get busing going. 11:29 I also believe there's enough to keep continuing going on the, on the red line. And for the rest of this, when you come up with a transparent plan that you've d- that, that you've worked on, then we can talk about it. 11:41 But another piece, I don't think this should all be on the back of, uh, the citizens of Charlotte. 11:48 I think the legislature should chip in money because Charlotte contributes a big hunk of the gen- to the general assembly's main, you know, income that comes in, comes off the back of Charlotte. 11:57 But I can't get any of that back for my roads? You know, the general assembly needs to give us some money. The federal government needs to give us some money. 12:06 And if Bank of America, Wells Fargo, Ally can put their names on stadiums and T-shirts, they can put them on bus shelters. They need to contribute too because their employees are the main ones riding. 12:16 When they come back with a plan like that, we'll be supported. But isn't it hard to get something like that? 12:22 I mean, if you do it completely out in the open, and if you, uh, you know, have all this buy-in, I mean, didn't, wasn't this kind of the way it had to be done to get it through the general assembly? 12:31 'Cause, you know, Charlotte doesn't often have a lot of great standing in front of the general assembly, so it had to be... I mean, they would say, "I think it's a negotiation. 12:38 We, we did the best we could, um, you know, in a difficult situation." And it wound up, incidentally, taking years, right? It wasn't that it happened overnight. 12:45 This is, they've been working on this for a number of years. Isn't that, aren't there political realities here that need to be addressed? 12:50 Yeah, there's, yeah, there's also public realities too, and the public realities is the people that always get shorted in this process are poor people, and as a general, Charlotteans as a whole. 13:01 The Blue Line went over budget. The Blue Line Extension went over budget. East Side was promised a lane down the center of the street that was gonna have BRT, then a shuttle, then high occupancy. 13:12 They didn't get any of that. The North Met was promised a red line for 30 years. 13:17 It's not the people's fault that they decided to put it out there and say, "We're gonna build you a line," when they didn't even know if they were gonna have permission for the line. 13:25 You know, these are the things that we're looking at. We're looking at a history of failures that folks then wanna come back and fix. You wanna know why we don't have upward mobility? Because we didn't have transparency. 13:36 This is why we have these type of issues. So don't go make a $30 billion mistake. You know, I would if we wasn't on the air say stop, but you know, down my back and telling me it's raining, because that's what they get. 13:48 And if you're a city councilman or a county commissioner and all you can always tell me is, "We can't do any better because of Dillon law," then I need to just talk to Dillon. I don't need to talk to you. 14:00 Let's just talk to the general assembly and stop selling yourself as being anything more than an advisory board, 'cause that's pretty much all you're telling me. You have no power. 14:09 I look at all of these different cities around the country that are in other Dillon Rule states, and they don't use that as a crutch as much as they use it here in North Carolina. 14:18 Texas is a huge Dillon Rule state, but Houston, Austin, Austin was one of the main places that we looked at as an example. All of those folks are in a Dillon Rule state, and you know why they have home rule? 14:29 'Cause they stood up and they fought for it. We don't stand up and fight for anything, but we'll sit back and say, "Here's the excuse of why we can't get it." 14:37 And I think you're seeing, Tony, not just on transportation, but Charlotte in general is getting tired of this. 14:45 And you're mentioning the Dillon's Rule state for people who aren't familiar, that's the, that's the way North Carolina is organized, that local governments can only do what the state government allows them to do, and you're, you're saying we need to kinda, kinda fight that, push some, push back a little harder on that. 14:58 Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, yeah, 'cause I can just tell you, anything, any time that it's something to do with the corporate community, Dillon figures out a way to rule in they favor. 15:06 But we need for it to happen on our terms, because the only say that the people have is in the voting. So vote this down, and we'll see what happens. 15:16 So the Charlotte Regional Business Alliance, which m- you've mentioned, uh, several times now, I mean, they came out a few weeks ago and said, for the Charlotte region, there are 157 people moving to the region every day. 15:28 So over the course of a year, that's, you know, more than 50,000 people moving to our region. If they all bring cars, that's- Yes... it doesn't, that's gonna cause more congestion. 15:36 It's gonna make it harder to get around, right? I mean, uh, what if, don't we need to do something on this right now? D- isn't, I mean, you know, the, the other side would say, "Look, we've waited far too long. 15:45 This is, we should've- Yeah... you know, this should've been done years ago, but we gotta do it now because the problem's only, with congestion, roads is only getting worse." 15:53 Well, I think what they ought to get to then is you're telling me about 157 people moving here daily to the region, we need a regional plan. We don't need a Mecklenburg plan. 16:03 We need for everybody to chip in, 'cause I mean, if it's a region, them moving to the region, they're not just moving to Charlotte, so they're still gonna drive in. 16:10 So then Cabarrus and Mooresville and Stanley and all these different places coming in, and we need a regional plan because just having them drive, they still gonna have to drive into Mecklenburg to park their car to get on the train, so you're still gonna be backed up. 16:25 You need to figure out a regional plan for a regional solution, and just putting it all on the back of Mecklenburg people isn't fair. And at the same time, you know who's benefiting around the region? 16:36 The people that don't have to pay the tax. 16:39 So if you're at the end of Mecklenburg County and you're at the, the other two or three counties that surround you are getting the benefit supposedly, but not paying the tax, then you're, people are gonna come and buy their gas there, or, you know, they're gonna come and buy their snacks there. 16:56 I go, I go to Rock Hill sometimes and buy stuff because it's cheaper. I know folks that definitely do it when it's school time. So don't tell me about a regional plan when you didn't make a regional authority. 17:06 Well, but you say- United all the people But I mean, they do say that a lot, because it's the sales tax and you have business travelers coming here, and you got people going to, you know, into Charlotte to come shopping, that some of that money- Definitely... 17:17 will be paid by people from outside- Oh, definitely... of Mecklenburg, right? They, they say it's about 30%, I think. Definitely. 17:23 Let's also add in, since I'm a low to moderate income people, the people that suffer the least, or the most, and that's the people that suffer from displacement. 17:30 So every time we come up with plans and don't have a good displacement plan, like this transportation plan, they admit doesn't have a good plan for displacement, you displace people. 17:40 And when you displace them, they go live in hotels and motels. And when they live in the motels, they're gonna pay the sales tax, they're gonna pay the hotel tax, which is 2%. 17:49 They're gonna pay the prepared food tax, which is 1%. 17:52 So not only does your plan displace people, but then you charge them a poor people tax for being displaced and try to sell me that the only people paying the tax are people visiting Charlotte. 18:04 Won't it hurt low income people if companies who would ordinarily move here decide they don't wanna move here because Charlotte hasn't addressed its transit and transportation issues? 18:13 The, the, the companies, you know, we're competing with Atlanta and Dallas and all these other places for, you know, jobs and corporate expansions and things like that. 18:22 I- if they decide to go elsewhere 'cause we haven't addressed some of these transit and transportation problems, doesn't that hurt low and moderate income people? 18:29 Well, one, I don't know how because most of the jobs that come aren't for low to moderate income people. 18:34 If low to moderate income people were benefiting from the 80 to $100,000 a year jobs that was coming to Charlotte, we wouldn't have a complaint. You know what I'm saying? 18:42 We would say we were getting a return on our money, but we're not. When what you get is you get other people coming to Charlotte. You know who comes to Charlotte when these companies move here? 18:53 That's those 157 people moving here today in the region. They didn't move here because they're Panther fans. They moved here because the job moved them here. Do you see my point? 19:02 Again, that's that rainwater down my back. Oh, and you tell me you're gonna get this federal match. 19:10 Well, one, I think the federal government as far as transportation, we're having a little problem with that right now on the safety issue, but not even touching that. 19:18 How are you gonna get a grant for $6 billion in federal financing in a competitive grant process when you can't even show projections on ridership? How they gonna give you some money on that? 19:31 Yeah, I mean, I think, uh, I mean, I, I think, you know, there's a lot to be figured out on that, you know, as far as what's, what's happening with funding from the federal level. And that's our problem, Charlie. 19:40 And that's our problem. Everybody keeps wanting us to vote for something we're gonna figure out. And you know, that's the Charlotte way. Vote for it and we're gonna figure it out later. 19:50 And then when the later comes, it's always off, and then we go do a study. And then after we do the study and the consultants make some money, we come right back to where we were again. 20:03 But I can tell you this could be a $30 billion mistake, and I can't in good faith ask poor people to pay for their own displacement. All right, well, we're just about out of time. Any final thoughts? 20:17 We've covered a lot of ground today, but anything, uh, anything else that you wanna hit? 20:22 Well, I think that the biggest thing that we didn't talk on that much is I don't think that this authority is set up, uh, to benefit, you know, regular people. 20:32 I think that the fact that you have to have all of these, uh, skills, you gotta be economic development, law, finance, all of that. Right. And this is set out in the legislation. It's a 27-member authority. Yeah. 20:42 And you have to have some background in- Yes, yes... in certain areas. Yes. 20:46 Yeah, so that means that if you care about active riders, the only thing that you're giving them the position to, to enable them to do is to serve on an advisory board, but they can't be a decision-maker. 20:57 Same thing with our employees. There is nobody, there's no requirement in there that anybody from labor serves on the board. So you're a transportation employee, there's no guarantee that you get a spot on the board. 21:09 But business gets three defined spots. The general assembly, who's given us no money, has three defined spots. Small business has two defined spots. 21:20 You add up all those defined spots, and you're talking about a power coalition that can make sure that the, the business interest is always done, the legislature's interests are always done. 21:32 And folks wanna see other folks in Charlotte and say, "Well, you're getting 27 seats." I bet you a bunch of those seats gonna be business people in those seats, too. All right. Well, Robert, thanks for the conversation. 21:44 Uh, I appreciate it. And, uh, it'll be interesting to see what happens. I know early voting starts in the middle of October, and we got the election in, in November. Thanks a lot for joining me. Yes, sir. Talk to you. 21:54 Well, that's a wrap. And to our listeners, thank you for listening. This episode of the Charlotte Ledger podcast was produced by Lindsey Banks. QueenCityPodcastNetwork.com. [upbeat music]