Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hey, it's Tony Mecia with The Charlotte Ledger, and you're listening to The Charlotte Ledger podcast. You can find out more about The Charlotte Ledger at thecharlott leger.com. 0:10 We cover a wide range of local topics, including business, education, community news, non-profits, and we do it with an approach that's smart, original, and interesting. So please check that out, thecharlott leger.com. 0:24 Today, we're sharing a conversation that I had with John Barton, the president of Northwood Office. Northwood is one of Charlotte's largest developers. 0:32 It's probably best known locally as the owner of the 535-acre Ballantyne Corporate Park, which it bought from the Bissell Companies in 2017. 0:41 In the last few years, Northwood has been working to transform the office park, the Ballantyne Hotel, and the surrounding area with its Ballantyne Reimagined project, which is starting now to come online. 0:52 But it's also active in other areas of Charlotte, like the Metropolitan in Midtown, as well as around the country. 0:59 John joined Northwood in 2018 from Atlanta, where he was the managing director and co-head of HFF's Office Investment Advisory Group. 1:08 He has 27 years of experience in commercial real estate and is a graduate of Southern Methodist University, and he also has a law degree from Washington and Lee. 1:17 In a conversation at Northwood's offices in Ballantyne in June of 2024, he and I talked about how and why Northwood went about the big Ballantyne transformation, what comes next, and more broadly, what the future looks like for real estate development in Charlotte and around the country. 1:34 And we also talked about how Charlotte can avoid becoming the next Atlanta. I hope you enjoy the conversation. John, thanks for joining me. Sure. Glad to be here. 1:43 All right, so you and I met each other, I think, in 2019 when you were announcing the Ballantyne Reimagined project. And, you know, there's, obviously, since then, there's been a lot going on in Ballantyne. Mm-hmm. 1:54 Um, you all have done a lot. 1:55 The, you know, I, I think it's a really interesting story, sort of what Northwood has done, uh, and I wanna definitely get into that, and especially at, at this really interesting time in commercial real estate. 2:05 But first, I wanted to start off a little bit personally. Your background is in law, I believe. You went to law school, Washington and Lee, right? Long, long time ago. Okay [laughs]. 2:13 I, I, uh- How did you make, I'm just curious- Yeah... how you made that transition- Well, I-... from law into commercial real estate. 2:17 So I tell everybody, I s- I, I went into law school with no intention of being a lawyer long term. I, I, I thought it would be, you know, the, the training would be good. 2:26 It would give me a lot of optionality in terms of want, what I wanted to do with my career. I could always support myself and have a profession, which was, um, something I thought was important. 2:36 But it really gives you a background to do a lot of different things. I was a liberal arts major in undergrad and a, a minor in business. Wow. 2:43 So I took a lot of really business-heavy classes in s- in school, and my intention was to practice for a few years and ultimately maybe work for a client or do something in business. I knew I wanted to run a business. 2:52 I just didn't know what. And so I did that for over a year, and then the CMBS market, commercial mortgage-backed securities, had just sort of begun forming. 3:03 This is back in the mid-'90s, and it was a very prolific market at the time. There was a lot of profits being taken. 3:10 Wall Street had started it, and it was, all the inefficiencies created a lot of opportunities and a lot of growth. 3:16 And so that's how I got into real estate, and, uh, underwrote every different product type, originated kinda everything. And so it was a great training ground for 3:26 a, a former lawyer and, you know, liberal arts major to, to really get into it, and I really, I loved it. 3:32 And so that's, that's how I got the start in it, and then after that, I've basically been in the office building business in one form or another since then. 3:39 I've done, uh, a, a little bit literally of everything since then. But joined Northwood in 2018, and I think you and I met at the first rezoning meeting perhaps- Mm-hmm... which would've been '19. 3:51 So moved here from Atlanta and have been very glad to be here ever since, so it's been a, a fun ride. Right. 3:57 I know you came here from Atlanta, and I'm not gonna put you on the spot and ask you if you're a Falcons fan, if you're an Atlanta sports fan. [laughs] I feel like that would be unfair. Yeah. 4:03 But so when, when you took this job, uh- Yeah... with Northwood- Yeah... uh, was the mission to kinda come in and take this asset here in Ballantyne and modernize it? 4:10 Had the plans already been laid and they needed someone to execute it? Yeah. How did, how did that come together? So there's, so a little context on Northwood, 'cause I think it answers the broader question. 4:20 Northwood is a, is a vertically integrated private equity firm, and we, one of the things that distinguishes us from some of our competitors is we have operating platforms that specialize in certain product types. 4:32 And historically, Northwood had retail, multi-hotels, a group we have in Europe called Urban Logistics, which is essentially like last mile, uh, distribution for Amazon or somebody, you know, smaller buildings. 4:45 What Northwood did not have was an office platform officially. We did through different local partnerships and joint ventures, but no official platform with a whole lot of structure. 4:56 And so in, when Northwood bought Ballantyne from Smokey Bissell in 2017, which predated me by roughly one year, basically Northwood ac- also acquired a, a large infrastructure and operating platform that Smokey had done a great job of building out with a whole lot of people. 5:14 And so the goal was to run Ballantyne, transform Ballantyne, do the things that were sort of conceived, um, at the acquisition, and I'll get to the, your fundamental question on that in a second. 5:27 But also, too, to run the other assets that our fund has throughout the United States. So that basically, 5:35 w- with the exception of the assets that had these sort of legacy joint venture partners and things in them, any new acquisitions Northwo- on office front, uh, Northwood would, Northwood Office would run. 5:47 And so the goal was to, you know, my, my, uh, goals and objectives for w- in joining, grow that platform, help, help facilitate our, our fund, buy as much as we can accretively and intelligently, and be able to run it in-house. 6:03 And we like that because we like our investors to have full transparency throughout, you know, the, the sourcing of it, the operating of it, and the selling of it, and total accountability and transparency. 6:14 Our, our founder was the former head of Blackstone's real estate a long time ago, and he was always very adamant about Transparency to the investors. And so that has very much remained a hallmark of what we do. 6:27 Having all this in-house capability in these different platforms is a critical piece of that. So since I joined, we've, we've, um, we've, we've definitely grown our, our footprint in terms of what we manage. 6:37 We manage, um, assets in, in, uh, Boston, Miami, Atlanta, Nashville, LA. We had something in San Francisco we actually sold out of, uh, a couple years ago, and in Seattle as well. 6:51 And so, and then obviously the stuff here, and we've, you know, we added Metropolitan Midtown during the pandemic. 6:56 And so it's been great because we've been able to grow, you know, capabilities of Northwood office beyond just Charlotte, which is, Smokey was pure Charlotte before. So that's been great. 7:06 But the largest asset in our fund is Ballantyne. In our global fund, this is the biggest asset. North- Charlotte and North Carolina are our largest investments globally. 7:16 So we're very focused on making sure that everything runs really well. But there's so much to do here with 535 acres, a former golf course. There was a lot of unlocked value that we needed to harvest. 7:28 And so part of the business plan was transforming that. 7:32 There are a lot of unknowns in the process, and a lot of that is figured out, you know, post-closing by hiring the best people we can to make sure that we get sort of international perspective. 7:43 That's when we brought in Sasaki as a master planner, but we want the local and regional perspective of land design, who'd done a lot of the master planning before, and a lot of other consultants and architects and things that, that are, are being used to sort of formulate the plan. 7:57 That started in earnest in '18. 8:00 I mean, there was a lot of interviewing of the master planners and sort of a competition there to see who we hire, but '18 is really when we kicked it off and, and that's when, that's when I'd started. 8:10 My predecessor, Ned Kern, who I know you know Ned. Ned w- was very civically involved and wanted to go do other things. 8:17 And so w- we, Northwood wanted to make sure that N- Ned's successor was in place before we sort of started the full thing because of the nature of it's multi-year. It's a, it's a big, it's a big undertaking. Right. 8:30 And, and Ned was gracious enough actually to work with us on it, which was great 'cause he was so involved, you know, historically with Bissell, and he's just, he's a, he's a great friend and great at what he does. 8:40 And so it's a pleasure to, to work with him and all the other pe- people we worked on. Yeah, I wanna talk a little bit more specifically about- Yeah... Ballantyne. 8:47 It's helpful knowing all, all the background on, on Northwood. But, you know, there is a lot of, of history here. I mean, not history- Yes... in the 100-year-old, uh, history, although- Yeah... 8:56 actually I've come to learn there are some historical sites, uh, in Ballantyne. But, you know, you think of Ballantyne being developed in the mid to late '90s, you know, the Harris family- Right... 9:04 the, the, you know, Bissells. You know, when I first came to Charlotte, my wife was from Charlotte. Mm-hmm. And my father-in-law lived actually pretty close to here. 9:11 Late '90s, when you came here, there was, like, a Target. There was the- Yeah... the pillars at the main intersection there on Ballantyne Commons Parkway. Maybe the movie theater had just opened up. 9:19 But it was, it was this big area, a lot of development. And since then, you know, in the last 20 years, it's really filled in. Yeah. And it's really changed. It was essentially far- farmland in, in the '90s. Oh, yeah. 9:29 And it was through the efforts of the people you mentioned, primarily Smokey, that, and Johnny Harris, that ultimately w- served as a catalyst for what it is today. 9:39 It's pretty amazing when you look at it, how fast it's happened and, and the magnitude of it. It's, it's very impressive. Oh, yeah. I mean, there's almost no developable land left, as I understand. 9:49 [laughs] I mean, there's a few pieces here and there, but it's, it's pretty, it's filling in pretty quickly. Yeah. And so as you said, you know, Northwood, you know, bought the, the office park, uh, you know, 535 acres. 9:59 That, that was a $1.2 billion transaction in 2017. That's a big investment. It is. So what was the thinking on we need to do something here? 'Cause, I mean, yeah, very nice hotel, very nice golf course. Mm-hmm. 10:11 You know, a lot of office space. What was the thinking on, okay, wh- here's why we need to do something big? Right. 10:17 So we, we fundamentally are a value investor, and, and when you look at something as the size of Ballantyne, it's hard to find things that are even remotely comparable that you can, you can acquire because it's just so big. 10:30 There are very few people that can do it, but to have the amount of potential that existed in the golf course, Smokey had always intended to at some point activate the golf course. 10:40 I think that, you know, he had, he'd gotten to the point in his career and he'd done very well. He decided he wanted to have somebody else do it. That's how we came in. 10:49 But, but our plan, and for context, we have, we, when we bought it, we had 40 office buildings over the 535 acres. Four hotels, different types of hotels. And this large 18-hole public golf course. 11:01 And so Northwood's plan was to come in. There were some sites that were immediately actionable that... 11:07 Like, for example, the Overlook office building that we built and delivered in May of '20, totally spec, meaning not pre-leased. Smokey had a history of that. 11:16 I think of the 40 buildings that he built, 37 were built totally spec. Only three were pre-leased. So there's been a history of success in, in doing that. 11:25 We delivered it in May of '20 in the pandemic at 0% leased, which was a bit of a nail biter. [laughs] That was a little bit rough. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it was... 11:32 W- we were a million dollars under budget and on time, but obviously the world had changed a lot in terms of pre-leasing. But today- Yeah, nobody's signing leases in '20, in the summer of 2020. 11:41 Not a good time to, to be doing that. But how- however, we did quite well with it. We're 99% leased today. And, um, and we got, we got leased up pretty well with the expansion of Credit Karma. 11:53 They're an existing customer, 30,000 feet here. They've grown to 225,000 feet and are about 75% of the building. We have, uh, many other customers as well. So that's been great. 12:02 At the same time, we were building 212 apartment units in Tower View right next door. And so that was sort of the immediate activation. 12:10 Then there was the long-term activation, and that's what led to the rezoning so that we could go in, transform the golf course, mai- still maintain lots of green space and a lot of things Ballantyne's known for, the walkability of the, the trails, the bikeability, the connectivity. 12:26 One of the things we did in the rezoning, as you know, is we built a bridge that connects into the greenway so you can ride your bike all the way up to Uptown and back. 12:33 But really activating that and creating almost a downtown for Ballantyne with a lot of amenities, both residential, you know, the apartments, the retail being the big focus. 12:44 We wanted to make sure that it was, it was vibrant and active and served not only our hotels, as well as the office and the community. 12:51 And also too, in the process, build a stream park that everybody can access and kids can play in. You see a lot of, you know, parents out there with their children, grandparents. It's great to see. 13:01 An amphitheater that'll hold about 5,000 people. 13:04 So we really wanted to transform not only our asset, but the entire south Charlotte community and make it really a regional asset and ideally one of the, one of the best mis- mixed-use projects in the Sunbelt. Mm-hmm. 13:17 And that was really our aspiration. So is the thinking... Is it part of a larger trend that... I mean, it used to be- Yes... 13:23 when it was built, you know, the idea that you could have an office park, and people would drive to the office park and then drive home. Yes. That was sort of the way it was, was looked at. 13:32 But I think th- that is changing, I think. If you look at, at, at development patterns, not just in Charlotte, but all over the place, you're starting to see some of these, you know, live, work, play- Yeah... 13:41 uh, things develop a little bit more. Was that part of the- Very much so... the thinking or you're tapping into that trend? Yeah. Yeah, very much so. That, and that, that trend has been going on for many years. 13:49 I, I think, if anything, the pandemic accelerated it even further because as, as employers have struggled to get people back to the office, part of getting them back to the office is giving them a reason to be in the office. 14:02 And so the importance of amenities, walkability, making work fun, so to speak, is, is all a critical piece. High quality, nice finishes, a good feeling is a big piece of... 14:15 If you look at the leases that are getting done throughout the United States, Europe has recovered much more favorably in terms of the hybrid work has not been as much of a problem there as it has been in the US. 14:25 But if you look at the, the vast majority of the leasing that's being done in the US, and Charlotte's no different, it generally tends to be in the, the well-amenitized, high quality, walkable properties. And, and the... 14:37 And frankly, the companies that are focusing on doing the leases there are less price sensitive. They really view the real estate as a, as a, as a h- as an HR cost. And so they just say, "Okay, if I have this space..." 14:50 Credit Karma's a good example. They put a lot of money into their space. They ha- It's tremendous space. 14:56 I, I won't go through all the amenities that they have, 'cause I don't know if they want me talking about, but there are a lot. Mm-hmm. And anything you can think of, they have there. 15:02 And part of it is their recruiting and their growth, I mean, going from 30,000 feet to 225,000, a lot of people to hire, and that's a- an important component. 15:12 The Bowl, which is what we call, as you know, the area where all the retail is that we've built and the, the residential tower, they're directly across from that. That was a big part of their decision. 15:22 And at the time that the building was being built and delivered, essentially, you know, we were literally excavating dirt out of there. 15:29 And it was a lot to sort of envision, but they had the forethought to see it and believe that we would do what we said we would do. Yeah. 15:36 One of the things that strikes me about it, 'cause I cover a lot of commercial real estate- Mm... talk to a lot of developers. 15:41 You know, you see all the time people put out renderings, or they have ideas of things they'd like to do, but you all have actually done it. I mean, the curtain is opening. 15:50 Your o- you know, Old Mecklenburg Brewing is open. You have a number of restaurants, North Italia- Mm-hmm... Flower Child. Mm-hmm. You guys are actually doing it. Yeah. 15:57 What does it take to actually get something on this scale done? I mean, it's a lot bigger. I mean, to your point, there, there are advantages to doing that, that you, you have... You control a lot of space. Right. 16:08 But actually doing it, is it different than doing smaller, kind of one-off projects, doing something on such a large scale? Definitely. You... 16:16 I think one of the most critical things in what we do is, first hiring the right people, both internally and externally, having the right partners and people that are wired to be collaborative and to be communicative, people that we don't have a bunch of, um, big egos that insist on getting their way on things. 16:37 We truly solve for what's the best outcome for our investors, for our customers, for the public, what we're trying to accomplish. 16:46 And I think that being very careful about who you hire and who you pick that sort of has that same f- philosophical approach is critical because I think where... 16:56 And this is one of the things that makes us competitive, 'cause we have all the different platforms, and we all work together. 17:01 We have every, o- other than urban logistics, I mean, every discipline that we have is reflected at Ballantyne. 17:07 In many developments, normally you have a developer that specializes in maybe residential, and that's, you know, brand X. 17:14 And then there's brand Y that does retail and brand Z that does office, and they're not ultimately controlled by the same sort of ultimate parent company. 17:24 And sometimes that can cause people to focus on only, like, their area, and sometimes that has negative impacts to the other groups that are involved. 17:34 Even though it's a, a one project and, in theory, everybody is incentivized to make the project great, sometimes that can present challenges. 17:42 And so I think that was one of the competitive advantages that we had is that, that we made sure that we had alignment across the board. We made sure that we, we had third... 17:52 You know, the third-party groups, some of which I mentioned earlier, had that same philosophy, and that we were ultimately solving for the best possible project we could in the aggregate. 18:01 Sometimes there are some compromises that have to be made in, on certain product types that we don't necessarily like, you know, in a vacuum, but they serve the overall purpose and good for the investment, and that's what we focus on. 18:13 Mm-hmm. So what's the next milestone? I mean, as we're talking, you're starting to open some of the retail and- Yeah... you know, you've got apartments under construction. Yeah. 18:20 I mean, what are some of the things looking forward- Yeah... what are some of the next steps that people are gonna see? So, so the next steps are we, we actually... We're very focused on getting our retailers open. 18:30 We're currently... We have signed leases on 80- 1% of what we've built and are, are building. And the Oro 26 story residential tower, 356 units, that's under construction, everything else is built. 18:44 The, the, the standalone jewel- jewel boxes and the different buildings are built. All of those buildings are leased with the exception of half of one, and there's a lot of activity on it. We're being pretty selective. 18:54 The demand has been really good, and we have some great retailers. North Italia, Flower Child are open. O&B open, as you mentioned, Post- not Postino, but Honeysuckle Gelato, the ice cream place. 19:05 But basically between now and, and roughly, you know, September-ish, you're gonna see a lot of openings. And I think that Hawkers is not gonna be open till January. 19:16 But basically bu- which is, um, an Asian gr- uh, group out of, um, South End, really great food. Mm-hmm. Excited about them. 19:23 So they're, they're the only sort of straggler of the ones that have been signed in January, and then all the others will basically be open over the coming months. 19:32 So it's been great, but then of course we're always planning for the future. 19:35 We were entitled, as you might recall, in phases one and two of the end- of the rezoning, I'm rounding a, a lot, but 2,000 apartments, 300,000 feet of retail. Wegmans, they're gonna use about 110,000 of that. Mm-hmm. 19:49 That's, that's on track, and people are... I had no idea how emphatic people are about Wegmans in the area. They're very emphatic. I mean, uh- I mean, have you seen these Facebook groups? Oh, yes. 19:59 And they're like 2,000 people. Yes. And they're talking about they're driving up to Raleigh to go get some- Oh, it's incredible... pierogis or something. I think. It's incredible. 20:05 And one of, one of my favorites after the announcement was made, one of the, one of the people had commented, "This is the best day of my life." [laughs] And I thought, "Boy, that's, that's quite a statement." 20:15 So we've been really happy. I think we have... We clearly have plans beyond that, so there's plenty to do. 20:22 And then there's a potential for even phase three later, to the extent that there's a major transportation event, whether it's light rail or widening of 521 that would trigger other entitlements as well. 20:32 But that comes with, you know, a- another traffic study, which means probably more infrastructure costs and things like that. 20:39 And as I've said to our team, [laughs] "We're out of the infrastructure business for the foreseeable future." We have spent, I think, about $110 million, for perspective, on that. So it's significant. 20:48 We have massively over-improved the, the road systems and everything for what we've built. 20:55 And so I feel really good about that because we've over-delivered in terms of what we told the politicians we would do and the community, and, and we really... That was a huge... That was very important to us. Yeah. 21:05 I mean, you all are definitely spending a lot of money, you know, to do this and, and to get this done. 21:10 And like you said, I mean, you're starting to see some of the payoffs and the, some of the numbers you mentioned, the people turning out to some of these retailers that are very well known. Yeah. 21:17 But what's it gonna take for Northwood? How do you benchmark the success for Northwood? I mean, like, you're laying out a lot of money. Right. 21:24 For this to work out, what has to happen, and how are you looking at it from a business point of view? 21:28 So if I, if I get straight to the point, the ultimate measure of success is, is what the sale price [laughs] is and what the profits are at the end. 21:37 I mean, to be blunt, there's a lot that happens in between, and there are milestones in between. 21:41 Unfortunately right now, as you know, the capital markets and, and equity markets, debt markets are in a lot of disarray, and so it's a challenging time. 21:51 But I look at it every day in terms of, are we, are we leasing more space? Are we providing the, the great mix of retail customers that overall enhance the, the whole thing? 22:03 So it really is a very highly symbiotic, uh, relationship that we have. And when you look at, we do a lot of mixed use generally, a lot of projects throughout the, the US. And, and it... 22:14 Those really, those assets are, are, they're sort of the, we refer to as a mixed use premium that you see because of the walkability, the amenitization, all the things that people want. 22:23 So normally you can get higher rents on your office, you get higher hotel rates, you know, everything benefits from that. All right, we're just about out of time. We got one final question for you- Yeah... 22:32 that I just wanted to ask because I know you are familiar with Atlanta- Mm-hmm... and now you're, you know, very familiar with Charlotte. Yeah. A lot of people are always saying, "We don't wanna be the next Atlanta." 22:40 [laughs] "We don't wanna develop and become the-" They say that in Nashville. They say it everywhere. [laughs] Yeah. So what- Yeah... 22:44 is Charlotte becoming the next Atlanta, and what are the lessons of development in Atlanta that we can apply in Charlotte? 22:50 Well, I was in Atlanta recently and, and I mean, traffic there is very significant and, and always has been. Atlanta's a great city. The demand for Atlanta and all the people moving there is tremendous. 23:03 And, uh, with the, with Hartsfield Airport and, and the number of people that are accommodated there, very diverse workforce, a very diverse economic base generally, great location. 23:14 Atlanta is a phenomenal city that I think will always do well. But frankly, the demand for being in Atlanta has far outpaced the transportation infrastructure. 23:24 They've made good improvements with the, a lot of the work around 285 and things like that there, and some of these toll, toll roads and things like that, that they, that they're adding. 23:34 They're sort of always under construction. They had MARTA, you know, their version, like light rail, their version of light rail, which runs from the airport and sort of all over. 23:44 And I mean, even back when I was first working in Atlanta, early 2000s sort of timeframe, we had a building, my old firm had a building on a MARTA stop. 23:53 And, and it was, you know, back then, like, it w- it wasn't as much of a focal point as it is today because, you know, people, the traffic wasn't as bad. 24:03 But as you look at the transportation infrastructure that they have, what they're doing with it, and the long-term planning, which they're very much on, I'm o- I'm on, um, a board down there, the Atlanta, uh, BeltLine. 24:14 It's a special services district advisory board. 24:16 And as you might, I don't know how much you know Atlanta, but there's an old abandoned, um, railroad line called the BeltLine, and all this great development has taken place on it. 24:24 And the amount of progress that's being made along the BeltLine, a lot of which is being done with federal funding, is tremendous. 24:31 I mean, it's really been a game changer in terms of, um, growth in Atlanta, and also the ability to open up the community to areas that, that pr- you know, in the past maybe haven't had access to that. 24:42 And I think that's been one of the themes of Ballantyne too, is, you know, we're Stream park, amphitheater, whatever. We're seeing people at Ballantyne that have really not been here before, and that's been outstanding. 24:54 I think the same is the case with Atlanta, but Atlanta fundamentally, you know, they've got... I mean, there've been issues with water and sewer. The federal government had to get involved. 25:01 I mean, a lot of these southern cities have infrastructure, you know. 25:05 You heard about stuff, like in the news a, a couple years ago with Jackson, Mississippi, and the, and the federal government had to take over the water system there. I mean, thankfully we don't have those problems here. 25:15 I think Charlotte, when people say Charlotte is becoming Atlanta, I can assure you as a, as a former Atlantan and s- and somebody who still goes there, we still own assets there, the traffic in Charlotte compared to Atlanta, no comparison. 25:28 It is... When I heard people complain about Char- uh, traffic in Charlotte, I was like, "You've got to be kidding me." I live in town. 25:34 My drive from Ballantyne, every way, every time of the day, no matter what, is 25 minutes. It's the easiest drive ever. 25:43 And, and so I know there are peak times on, you know, 45 and 77 can be a bit challenging from time to time. But I think that overall we're doing well. Do we need to think about the future as it relates to the light rail? 25:55 Of course. And we plan for that in our rezoning. I mean, we actually have a reservation of land that would run the blue line over through the park with three stops. 26:05 That's one of those things that would trigger that last phase of, of development potentially, or entitlement rather. Again, subject to a traffic study and, and m- and more improvements in terms of traffic mitigation. 26:16 But I think the city knows that we need to be ahead of it. The challenge is getting the political fortitude to advance a lot of those things. But there's also a key fact, and that's funding. 26:28 Because even though the federal government might fund a lot of this stuff, there's always a local match, always. 26:33 And, and the studying and everything that happens, and when we get back to the ta- topic about the taxes and sort of the tax base being impact because of all these commercial buildings, there's less money to do things like that. 26:46 So again, we need to get all these income pr- you know, formerly income-producing properties back to producing income in a way that's financially feasible for the private sector, because the government can't do it on its own. 26:58 It's just not gonna happen. All right. That sounds like a good, good place to- [laughs]... to end it. Unless you've got anything else you wanna add. 27:03 I think that's, uh, it's, I thank you for your objective reporting, Tony. You've always done a very nice job. Well, thank you very much. I appreciate you sitting down with me. Yep, glad to do it. All right. 27:12 Good luck with everything. Thank you. Okay. That's a wrap. To our listeners, thank you for listening. Charlotte Ledger Podcast is produced by Lindsay Banks. QueenCityPodcastNetwork.com