Transcript 0:01 The Charlotte Ledger Podcast is a member of the Queen City Podcast Network. [upbeat music] Hey, it's Tony Mecia with the Charlotte Ledger, and you're listening to the Charlotte Ledger Podcast. 0:14 You can find out more about the Charlotte Ledger at thecharlotteledger.com. 0:19 This episode of the Charlotte Ledger Podcast is presented by SouthPark Community Partners, an independent nonprofit organization whose mission is to lead SouthPark's advancement by driving economic vitality, creating memorable experiences, and ensuring an extraordinary quality of life. 0:36 Visit southparkclt.org and follow SouthPark Community Partners on LinkedIn and on Instagram and Facebook @southparkclt to learn more about the way SouthPark supports the Charlotte region's economy. 0:51 I'm talking today with Shannon Binns, the founder and executive director of Sustain Charlotte. 0:56 It's a nonprofit organization that advocates and educates around issues like sustainable development, smart growth, transit, and other urban issues. Shannon, thanks for joining me. Thanks for having me, Tony. 1:08 Great to be here. Well, I'm really excited about talking with you about this topic. 1:12 I'm really interested in what you're doing and in your perspective, 'cause at the Charlotte Ledger, you know, one of the things we really try to cover well is this topic of growth and development, and that's been a big theme- Mm-hmm... 1:22 in Charlotte going back decades. You know, we're a growing region. Absolutely. There are a lot of positives in being a growing region. There are a lot of advantages to that. 1:29 There are also some negatives in that, and the, this question of how our region grows is just absolutely vital, and I know there are different ideas on that. What is your idea of how Charlotte should grow? 1:41 It's a great question, and it's really the reason we exist. You know, I moved here in 2007, noticed exactly what you just described, you know, this incredible growth, 1:51 but also a lot of the negative impacts that come with that growth. So, you know, the idea of this organization and what we're really focused on is how can we grow in a more sustainable way? 2:02 How can we grow in a way that is better for the long term, you know, not just looking at maybe what's best in the short term from an economic standpoint, but e- economically, environmentally, and from an equity perspective, what does, what does growth need to look like? 2:17 So, you know, we're focused on decisions and policies around land use and development, much like you guys are at the Ledger, as well as transportation, how we, how we move around, uh, the city and the region. 2:28 So for us, it's, um, keeping in mind the long term, you know, what, what, what do we need to do to have a, a healthy, a safe, uh, community, a vibrant, a vibrant economy now and into the future, and really a, a place that has, is, is livable and affordable for everyone, not just, not just some of us. 2:48 So how- Yeah... what's the CliffsNotes version of how you do that? Like, what, I mean, as a region, like, how do we, how do we grow more equitably? How do we make sure people have affordable places to live? 2:58 I mean, how do we make sure we have a, the lifestyle that people want as, you know, um, lots of people pour into this area? Yeah. 3:05 So I think, you know, what we really need most in terms of making the area more livable, more affordable, more convenient to move around is we need diversity. We need diversity of housing types. 3:18 We need small h- you know, smaller housing types like apartments, you know, up to single-family homes, and all the different housing types in between, what's often referred to as the missing middle housing. 3:28 By providing a variety of housing types across the community, we're able to provide affordable price points for more people, given that, you know, people have a range of household, you know, family in- incomes. 3:39 Similarly, we need a diversity of transportation choices. 3:42 Kind of in a similar fashion, you know, there's on, on the one extreme, the, in the extreme that we've been most focused on, like most American cities, is assuming everyone will want to and be able to get around th- with a private, with a private car. 3:55 But we need other transportation choices because, frankly, private cars don't work for everyone. Not everyone c- can, has access to one or have the, has the ability to use one or frankly wants to use one. 4:05 So, you know, at a very high level, I think when we and other cities grow in a way that prioritize a diversity of housing, diversity of transportation, and build our communities in a more efficient way, that's when we, that's when we move in a more equitable and, and environmentally sustainable way, and a more economically sustainable way. 4:25 Well, great. I'd, I'd love to drill down on these, um, a, a little bit more. Maybe, um, let's start with transit. 4:31 I mean, I, I know that's something you've been very, um, involved in, and a, a lot of times when people think of transit, they think of, you know, light rail or they think buses. 4:39 And I, I know that, you know, the vision for that really is a little bit broader, you know, bike lanes and greenways and sidewalks, you know, what's become sort of known as multimodal or, or a mobility plan. 4:51 Certainly Charlotte, you know, has been talking about it certainly and has a lot of ideas about it over the last few years. And- Yeah... 4:57 at the Ledger, you know, we started a newsletter in 2021 called Transit Time, and, uh, we did that with WFAE and UNC Charlotte's Urban Institute. 5:04 And at the time, the thinking was, okay, the city's getting ready to really move this transit plan forward to go to a vote this year. Okay. And, uh, we need to k- step up and cover that. That was 2021, and 2021 passed. 5:14 There was no, no vote, didn't really move forward. 2022 passed, 2023 passed. 5:19 We're now in 2024, and it seems like in many ways like we're no farther along in getting to that comprehensive transit plan or mobility plan than we were three or four years ago. I, is that frustrating? 5:31 I mean, should- Very... people who wanna see that be frustrated? Or wha- It, it, it- What's the right way to think of that? It's very frustrating. 5:36 Much like you, we, we did some things in 2021 to kinda prepare for what we thought would be a, um, a one-cent sales tax, you know, moving ahead and being on the local ballot for voters to decide whether they wanna increase their, their taxes to support transportation investments. 5:51 And yes, it's been very painful to see that not, not go forward, uh, each year since then. 5:57 And, you know, even prior to 2021, going back at least as far as 2015 You know, our Metropolitan Transit Commission convened a finance working group, a transit finance working group clear back then and, you know, recognized at that point that we needed major new sources of additional funding to carry out our transit plan. 6:14 So we've been paying attention since before twenty fifteen, but certainly this is a conversation that's been, that's dragged on for a long time, um, with kind of the most recent iteration being the, the one set sales tax that started to, to come, to come forward in twenty twenty-one. 6:29 So what needs to happen for that to move forward, and why hasn't that moved forward, and why is that important to move forward? Why hasn't it happened? 6:37 I think that really comes down to the fact that we have not, you know, been able to build either, you know, both the, the robust local support as well as the support in the state legislature that's, that's needed to move that ahead. 6:50 I think, you know, at the local level, I think everyone knows that part of the, the transit plan for our region included a rail line, uh, to the north of the county through Cornelius, Huntersville, and Davidson. 7:02 And because of a broken agreement essentially with, uh, Norfolk Southern who owns those tracks, uh, that, that project has not come to fruition, not for lack of trying, certainly on CATS or Charlotte's part. 7:14 But that hasn't happened, and therefore, you know, residents and, and town leaders, uh, in the north have felt they have not received what they were promised when they started paying into the half-cent sales tax, you know, a couple of decades ago. 7:26 So that's been part of it. 7:27 And then I think that, you know, similar, on a sim- in a similar vein, we've, we've seen, you know, the, the legislative leadership not be supportive, at least in, in rhetoric and, and what they've said publicly in a, a plan that would be multimodal for our region that does involve expanding transit, walkability, bike lanes, greenways and so forth. 7:47 So there's a lot of politics involved, but at the same time, you know, I, I believe that there's a good chance something will move forward this year. 7:55 I think there's a lot of work that is being done and underway to both, you know, craft an agreement, Norfolk Southern, to use those tracks, but also I think efforts to work with the leadership in Raleigh to really make the case that, you know, from, from an economic standpoint alone, this is a really important investment that, 8:13 that we should allow residents here who pay taxes to make a decision on for themselves and at least give us that opportunity to decide if that's what we wanna do. So what is the case for, for moving that forward? 8:24 You know, it, it has a lot of moving parts in it. I mean, the, the most expensive part of it is the light rail. I think it's a thirteen point five, the last numbers I saw, thirteen point five billion in light rail. 8:35 The rail portion is, I think, eight plus. There are also, you know, sidewalks, greenways, you know, more mobility types of things. What is the case that that actually needs to get done? 8:45 Like, why does that have to happen? 8:48 Well, the reality is we are a fast-growing urban area, and urban areas around the world and a reliance solely on moving people or primarily moving people in, in vehicles, cars and trucks, simply doesn't work in urban areas. 9:05 It works in rural areas. It works in, you know, places, you know, lower population centers. 9:10 But as, as areas become more populous, become more urban, there-- because, um, of limited land availability, it's, it's sort of the simple question of there's only so much land, but, uh, cars take up, uh, an enormous amount of space on a per person basis. 9:26 So, you know, your streets can only be widened so much before, uh, you start to run into other things like houses [chuckles] and buildings and parks and things that people need to get to. 9:36 And transit, walking, biking, these modes are just m- simply more efficient ways to move people from that land, you know, use perspective. 9:44 Not to get too wonky, but you can just visualize how much space you need to move, you know, ten people on a bicycle versus ten people in a car, or a hundred people by car versus a hundred people on a bus. 9:57 So that's why cities, uh, urban areas in general move to other transportation modes, simply because without doing so, you have major gridlock and no one, no people and goods cannot get to the places that they need to go. 10:11 Yeah, I mean, these things are all kind of tied together, the, the transit and transportation and land use. I mean, how much... You know, this is a city that kinda grew up around the automobile. 10:21 And if you look at our development patterns over the last few decades, you know, we have a lot of single family subdivisions out in the suburbs. And if that weren't the case, if y- you know, it... 10:31 You know, you think of the, the older, older cities, you know, your Chicagos and your New Yorks, where the, the transit lines, you know, work, work pretty well. 10:38 How much are, is Charlotte hampered by the fact that we are so spread out and that we have... I mean, the, the, those density numbers are, you know, they're pretty low, I think, relative to other cities. 10:50 We're, we're geographically one of the larger cities. I mean, how much does that kinda make that effort tough? It makes it really tough. I mean, we are, we are one of the lowest density. 10:59 I think one study considered us the lowest density city, major city in the world. 11:03 It does make it difficult because in order for walking and biking and transit to work, you have to have, you know, a certain level of density. Things have to be somewhat close together. 11:13 It is difficult to efficiently and, and, you know, affordably serve, you know, provide transit service across a three hundred square mile city, and that doesn't include, you know, the entire county that CATS, uh, works, works to serve and partner with. 11:28 So it, it's a challenge, but, you know, the reality is land is being developed all the time. You know, ci- cities by their nature are always changing, as you know. 11:38 So we have this opportunity as redevelopment occurs to redevelop in a way that makes these other modes of travel more possible. 11:46 So it comes down to really better urban planning and in many cases, you know, higher density development. But not just higher density of one type, but a mix of, of land use types. 11:58 So mixing housing with businesses, with grocery stores, you know, the village concept. That type of thoughtful planning allows people to get to the places they need to go. 12:09 Um, more easily without having to, to drive a long distance. 12:12 So if, you know, the neighborhood is built with sidewalks, bike lanes, good, good bus service, um, and the places they need to go, the destinations are rela- you know, relatively close to each other, then those modes become much more viable and make a lot more sense. 12:28 But yes, as you mentioned, the historic pattern that we as a, and many other Sun Belt cities, you know, who grew up during the, the, the age of the automobile, you know, have done, we've grown these subdivisions that are very reliant on cars, and it's, it is difficult to retrofit, but it's not impossible. 12:43 And we see other cities around the country who are on s- in a similar place, you know, fixing it. 12:49 It's not easy, but it does require changing development patterns and changing what types of investments we make when it comes to transportation. So with roads, it doesn't mean we don't do anything new with roads. 13:02 It means that we redesign our roads so that they are safer for people not driving as well as walking, biking, using transit, right? 13:10 So there's investment in roads are needed, just the shift is cities are really moving away from building for a single mode of travel, i.e. 13:18 cars, and building what are called complete streets so people have multiple ways of moving within, within the corridor of that road or that street. 13:26 Yeah, I mean, it seems like one of the issues on this transit plan is that, you know, the, most of the local leaders, not 100%, but most of them I think are on board with this idea of what you're saying, of let's, you know, multimodal options for people, you know, 10-minute neighborhoods, that kind of thing. 13:41 But, but then, you know, the folks in Raleigh say, "We need to focus on roads because- Mm-hmm... 90% of the people drive cars, and we need to service... 13:50 And then the traffic is getting worse, and we need to take care of the people who drive cars." Like, what's the, what's the matter with that- Yeah... way of thinking? Is, is that, is that accurate? 13:59 Or what would you say to people who say, "Okay, we need to look out for the- Sure... the interests of people who are driving cars"? 14:06 You know, intuitively, I think a lot of people do think, "Gosh, you know, if, if there's a lot of congestion on the road, we just need to widen the road." 14:14 But what happens when, when you do that, when you, when you widen a road or add more road capacity, it actually attracts more drivers. So people tend to drive more the faster the traffic is moving, the easier it is. 14:26 So it doesn't provide that long-term congestion relief that you intuitively expect when you add road capacity. The opposite actually happens. 14:34 You have, you may have relief for a very short time, but invariably, that, um, extra capacity is absorbed by new drivers, um, especially if you're a growing city attracting, you know, more and more population. 14:46 So you only buy yourself some congestion relief for a short time, and then, and then things are worse than they were before. 14:53 Beyond, in addition to that, in addition to the fact that, unfortunately, that solution does not solve congestion, which is what is most people's primary concern, it also, that approach doesn't address many other issues that cities need to, need to be, um, concerned with. 15:09 Equity, for one. It doesn't take into account the fact that here in Charlotte alone, 13,000 households don't have access to a car, and about a third of Charlotteans can't drive. 15:21 So when you design a city for a single mode, you're really leaving out many, many people where driving is not, um, possible for them. From a climate perspective, 15:33 you know, we are still, uh, driving around and, and most of us have many fossil fuel plants under our hood. We're burning gasoline, uh, which of course is a green- is, is emitting greenhouse gas emissions. 15:44 And, and here in the city, transportation is the largest source of climate pollution or greenhouse gas emissions by sector. It's 40% of our emissions. Regionally, it's 44%. 15:55 Another downside of just, just building more roads is that when we do that and we have that heavy reliance on vehicles, we also run into a lot of health problems. 16:04 The largest source of air pollutants in Mecklenburg County is from tailpipes, vehicle tailpipes. 16:10 You also, in communities where people are unable to move through active transportation, walking, biking, even, even if that's walking or biking to a transit station, you find higher levels of obesity and heart disease and diabetes and other, uh, chronic medical conditions that, you know, sitting in your car a lot can, can exacerbate. 16:31 Last thing I'll mention is just from an economic competitive standpoint, you know, only focusing on building cars will not, has done a number of things. 16:41 Uh, one, many employers are now looking to locate in cities that have diverse transportation networks and m- and multiple ways for their employees to get to work, in part because it's the quality of life issue, and they know that people want to live in walkable, bikeable, transit-rich communities. 16:58 So it's important from an economic competitiveness standpoint that we don't just limit ourselves to building for cars. 17:05 We also know from a 21, 20- 2021 study that was done here in North Carolina about our plan was that if we don't do anything, if we just kind of continue to grow in the way we have grown, we could lose, uh, up to 126,000 unrealized jobs, 28 billion in economic outputs, and 3 billion in tax revenue by 2050. 17:27 So I know that's a long list, but the reality is we tend to think about, oh, we just need to fix congestion. And unfo- unfortunately, not only does it not fix congestion, it, it, a lot of other problems. 17:38 And I didn't mention safety. You know, the number of fatalities and serious injuries that exist in a city like Charlotte that is really focused on moving cars as quickly as possible results in a number of people. 17:50 Last year alone, 70 people were killed due to traffic violence. Uh, I think this might be the highest source of death outside of homicides, um, in Charlotte. 18:00 So it's, there's a lot of reasons why we have to look beyond just moving cars around our region. We'll be right back to the conversation. 18:08 But first This episode of the Charlotte Ledger Podcast is presented by SouthPark Community Partners, a nonprofit organization whose mission is to lead SouthPark's advancement. 18:20 Yeah, you hit on a lot of interesting points there. I mean, you know, you think where employers wanna locate. I mean, if you look at where all the hot office buildings are now, they're in South End, right- Mm-hmm... 18:29 along the, the light rail line because- Yeah... that's where employers wanna be. It's sort of, and, you know, you think about a walkable... 18:35 I mean, there, there are a lot of amenities, amenities there, and this, this idea of the- Right... the office park is kind of now considered, well, it was hot 20 or 30 years ago, is now sort of an, a little bit outmoded. 18:47 That the i- this idea that you would drive to these huge surface parking lots, park, and walk into a, a sort of sterile, uh, office park with, you know, nowhere to go for lunch around it is a little bit, it's a little bit antiquated. 18:57 So you're seeing things all around the city, and really all around the country, in urban areas, trying to kind of tap into that a little bit. 19:04 And so it's like a little bit of a question of how do you, how do you make that happen r- large? Right. 19:09 And, and also realizing so many cities are so much further along, uh, than Charlotte, especially when you move beyond the Sun Belt, uh, in, in terms of these other ways of getting around. 19:18 You know, we- we're competing, um, with those cities for talent, right? For, for people. 19:25 And, you know, I think for people who are used to those sorts of cities where they have, you know, things within walking distance, and they can ride their bike, and they can hop on a greenway, and they can use transit, you know, if they come to visit Charlotte, you know, or even move here, you know, that's, that's not a mis- that's gonna be a, a barrier for some people. 19:44 It's, it's not a small factor anymore. I think people do care about those issues. You also mentioned the, uh, development patterns around roads. 19:51 It's funny, uh, my wife and I were cleaning out our attic the other day and, you know, I, I used to work for the Charlotte Observer so I saved some old, you know, remember newspapers? Mm-hmm. 19:59 I used to save the old newspaper when, it was my first, uh, 1A headline about a bus hijacking. But the rest of the stuff in there, it was interesting. 20:06 It was a six-part series The Observer did in 1997 on I-485, and it's called I-485: Here It Comes. [laughs] You know? 20:14 And, uh, it's, you know, s- so it talks about how you use three million tons of asphalt and concrete to build it this, you know, before it, it opened really. It said, you know, looked at some of the pluses and minuses. 20:24 You know, commuters who now drive 30 minutes to work can cut their trips in half. Residents of towns outside Charlotte will gain easier access to the stores, restaurants, and theaters around the region and the city. 20:33 Farmland once populated by cows and corn will soon disappear. Uh, it turned into two-car garages and 24-hour grocery stores. And it says, "But it's not without a price. 20:42 Some fear more air pollution, heavier traffic congestion, more suburban sprawl with fewer human connections, the end of a quieter, calmer lifestyle." So even, you know, in 1997, some of these- Mm-hmm... 20:53 things were kind of recognized a little bit. 20:55 And if you look at, uh, you know, one of the things [laughs] that the house speaker was complaining about is the interchange at, at 485 and, and 85 and, you know, these, these issues just sort of, they don't go away necessarily because you build a big outer belt. 21:09 No. I mean, that, that's just it. We, we've known for a long time and, you know, we can look at our own experience like you, you just did. 21:16 You know, the, the predictions in that article from, from 1996 have come true, I would argue. But, you know, we've... 21:24 You can look at so many cities around the country and around the world who have taken the approach of, "Well, we can just pave our way out of this mess," and it's never, it's never worked. 21:32 [laughs] They've always ended up back where they were with just worse congestion and wider roads, and a lot of asphalt they have to spend a lot of money to, to, to maintain. 21:42 Uh, on land use, I know you all have been involved on the Unified Development Ordinance and the Charlotte 2040 comprehensive plan. How do you think that is going? 21:52 I know the city's, you know, starting to operate under these new rules. 21:55 You know, there'll be some modifications coming that they've already made, but w- how do you, uh, how would you describe that process and where we stand on that? Yeah. Well, it, it, it's exactly like you said. 22:06 I think, you know, the city's learning a lot, you know, as they implement the new, the new rules around development, the UDO, Unified Development Ordinance. 22:14 You know, discussing some changes, the, you know, some unintended consequences that they, they have popped up. 22:20 But, you know, I think still fundamentally it's a, it's a set of rules that is vastly better than what we had before. 22:27 The comprehensive plan envisions a very different, uh, city than w- what I think we've articulated in the past. 22:35 So, you know, it'll take time, and it will take a lot of, I think, political will to honor, you know, to honor those rules and to honor the plan. 22:44 We, uh, we know that, you know, rezonings are the idea right with the new comprehensive plan, and the UDO is that we would, you know, reduce the number of rezoning requests because we would, would be allowing, you know, more flexibility in, in the law. 22:57 And I don't think we've seen that yet, but I, I think that, that's always, that was the ideal, is maybe ho- you know, raise the design standards, but provide more flexibility and more, more reliability so developers know what they, what they can build. 23:11 So I think, you know, it's too early to say, but, you know, we, we believe in those plans. 23:16 Uh, we believe in the plan, we believe in the, in the, the rules, and now it's a matter of, you know, implementing those rules and making changes as needed. But fundamentally, we think that we're on the right track. 23:28 One of the things, as you know, that was one of the main areas of concern when it was passed was this idea that you're, they're gonna start being non-single family homes in neighborhoods that are right now composed at almost entirely of single family homes. 23:43 And, you know, and I certainly, I, I think people understand the y- you know, concerns about gentrification, you know, housing prices, that sort of thing. 23:51 What would you say to people who don't like the idea of duplexes or triplexes, you know, being built in their communities? Well, yeah. 24:00 There's certainly, uh, a lot of that, and I think the reality is that, you know, when, when someone decides to move to a city, one thing that, you know, I think we, we fail to keep in mind at times that- The nature of the city is that it's always changing. 24:15 You know, cities are not static, um, places. If they are, they're usually, you know, dying or, or, you know, not, not growing economically. So, you know, when a city is successful and vibrant, then there are changes. 24:31 And when you, when you choose to live in a growing city, you have to expect that you're, you're going to have more neighbors. People have to live somewhere. 24:40 And for reasons we talked about earlier, there's a lot of benefits to increasing housing diversity and having various price points, different sizes of homes, and having a mix of rental as well as owner-occupied homes. 24:55 You know, we need to have homes for everyone. 24:57 Not everyone can afford a single-family home, but that doesn't mean they shouldn't be able to live in a particular city or a particular part of the city, um, especially if that's where their work is or their child's school. 25:08 So, you know, I think there's an equity component to this about allowing people to live close to their work or, you know, the part of the city that they want to work, want to live and work in. 25:18 But it also is the practical reality is when you have, you know, over 100 people moving to this area a day, you know, they have to live somewhere. 25:28 And, you know, putting people further and, you know, just building single-family homes on the outskirts of the city is, is simply, you know, not sustainable. 25:35 We will run out of, of land for that, and we will continue to create this dependency on, on automobiles, which then leads to the congestion that we're now suffering from. 25:46 So I think you have to really look at how, how all of that comes into play and, you know, if people say, "I don't want more congest-" You, you can't say you don't want more congestion and then sort of be in favor of suburban sprawl, because suburban sprawl is a recipe for, for more congestion. 26:01 What sort of things is, uh, Sustain Charlotte working on nowadays? I know you all, it seems like you always have sort of regular events, panels- Mm-hmm... discussions. 26:09 What, what sort of things are on your radar for the rest of this year? Yeah. So, you know, we're working on all these things, keeping a close eye on, on the sales tax and continuing to be an advocate for that. 26:21 But we're also, right now we have, um, an effort where we're, uh, engaging residents and, um, helping them use their voice to advocate for more, uh, funding for park and rec. 26:31 Park and rec, you know, we believe continues to be underfunded relative to community needs across the county, so we're simply asking for, uh, more funding for land acquisition, uh, which the county's done a great job over the last two years, um, putting aside, uh, 50 million for land acquisition. 26:48 We were asking them to continue that again this year. That's to buy land for future parks and greenways, nature preserves. 26:55 Uh, also just increasing the, um, the amount of staff, uh, that the department needs to grow, um, as the need for more, um, park and rec, um, facilities grows. Things like that. 27:06 So we're kind of in the midst of a campaign, if you will, to secure, uh, count- county commi- Mecklenburg County Commission support for, you know, funding for parks and rec. 27:15 We're also, um, starting to look at, um, best to ask the city to increase, uh, funding, uh, for their bicycle program. 27:24 The, um, city has what they call their bike program as well as their pedestrian program and their Vision Zero program. 27:31 Um, these are all, you know, attempts to make improvements to the street network for safer walking, biking, and in the case of Vision Zero, driving as well. Those are funded through the city's CIP. 27:42 And for the next three bond cycles, the funding for Vision Zero and the pedestrian program are slated to go down significantly from the last cycle, bond cycle, and bicycle funding remains flat at just 4 million per year. 27:57 So we'd like to see the bicycle funding go up from 4 million a year to 10 million a year in the CIP. And again, this is, this becomes especially important because, you know, the sales tax, uh, has not moved forward. 28:10 You know, our needs around making our city more m- multimodal have only grown, and yet the funding for these additional modes, namely bi- biking and walking, have, uh, decreased in our, in our future plans for our, for our CIP, for our bonds. 28:26 So, so we'll be, we'll be making an ask for the city to consider increasing at least the bike program funding and hopefully, you know, restoring higher funding for Vision Zero and, and the pedestrian program too. 28:37 So if somebody is listening and likes what you're saying, what is a way for them to get involved with Sustain Charlotte? So lots of ways. 28:44 Uh, of course, we have a website, sustaincharlotte.org, and when you land on there, you can sign up for our newsletter, which goes out once a week, and that's filled with information as well as ways to get engaged, ways to, opportunities to be more, more involved in these issues and, and weigh in, uh, when the, when the city or the county is asking for input on plans and policies. 29:05 Of course, we're on all the social media handles, or social media pa- uh, uh, sources as well. So you can find us on all of those, on X and Facebook and Instagram, of course, and, and YouTube. 29:17 So lots of ways to get involved and we, we try to share, we share those opportunities quite frequently how people can, can get involved, whether it's signing a petition or, you know, engaging in an activity, coming to an event. 29:29 We've got our sustainability awards coming up in April, our 12th annual, so we're seeking nominees right now for our sustainability awards and then we've got lots of other events throughout the, throughout the, the year that they can find on our events page. 29:42 Great. Is there anything I, I didn't ask you about that you think is important to know? 29:46 Well, I think that one thing I was going to mention around other policies we might want to consider, you know, we, one thing we might also be advocating for later in the year is, uh, for CATS to have the financial and human resources to restore their frequency of, of bus and streetcar service that were in place prior to August of 2022. 30:05 You might remember that frequency on about a dozen routes was cut, and they're bringing back that frequency, but it's, it's being brought back slowly and I think a lot of it has to do with the driver shortage. 30:16 Um, but, you know, that's- Getting service back to at least those, those levels, um, is something we'd like to see. 30:23 You know, service levels need to be improved even further, but if we can at least get back to where we were, you know, prior to, um, 2022, that would be, that would be good for people who are, you know, using our transit system today. 30:34 And another thing I'd just mention is at the state level about highway, um, is it 521 in Ballantyne and the transportation, um, the STIP, the Strategic, Strategic Transportation Investment Law. 30:46 Um, back in 2013, the legislature put a restriction in that law that does not allow standalone bicycle and pedestrian projects to be funded by the s- by the state. 30:55 Local- localities cannot apply for state funding for more bike and pedestrian standalone projects, and we'd like to see that restriction repealed, um, because that does, you know, really put all the burden on, um, towns and cities to come up with the funding for those projects. 31:10 Oh, yeah. 31:10 I think, I think wasn't there one going through University City where the city actually stepped up and paid some money, or the, maybe it was University City Partners or somebody and, they had to step in and actually do it 'cause the state won't do- Right... 31:22 sidewalks and, you know- Exactly... in urban areas. That's right. You know, in, in high, you know, where there are a lot of pedestrians, you know? Exactly. Exactly. Yeah, so that's what I was referring to. 31:30 So, you know, if that was, that's just a state level policy that, the big state level policy change, of course, that we, we want to see is the authority to give ourselves the, the chance to vote on a tax. 31:41 But, you know, secondary, uh, a secondary one would be, you know, repealing that, that restriction to open up more state funding for, for, uh, walking and biking infrastructure. And that's across the state, of course. 31:53 Great. Well, that's all the questions I have. Shannon, thank you for joining me. Yeah, of course. Of course. Okay, that's a wrap. To our listeners, thank you for listening. 32:01 Charlotte Ledger Podcast is produced by Lindsey Banks. 32:05 This episode of the Charlotte Ledger Podcast was presented by SouthPark Community Partner, a non-profit who leads SouthPark's advancement by driving economic vitality, creating memorable experiences, and ensuring an extraordinary quality of life. 32:21 QueenCityPodcastNetwork.com. [outro jingle]